i may get in trouble

[bullet tooth t0ny]

i think i might get into trouble for this but here goes.

do you guys think its right to sell a 2' juwel tank with 10 carp in it.

[alphakenny1]

i think its absoloutly stupid, these fish are river or pond fish, not tank fish

[mrchimps]

im not judging.

why not sell the tank and sell the carp or give them away seperatley?

[mike515]

yeah it is wrong. Completely out of order.


And unlike Mr chimps I am judging. The seller is a knob to be honest.


You can see the photo and it's clearly overstocked. I don't have a problem with carp inside, they grow quicker and produce more waste. But they are not affected by living inside from a health point of view.

Yes carp should have much larger accomodation. Outdoor ponds are ideal because indoor ponds are too much for many people. But otherwise massive tanks inside are fine for them.

[bullet tooth t0ny]

Originally Posted by mike515

yeah it is wrong. Completely out of order.


And unlike Mr chimps I am judging. The seller is a knob to be honest.


You can see the photo and it's clearly overstocked. I don't have a problem with carp inside, they grow quicker and produce more waste. But they are not affected by living inside from a health point of view.

Yes carp should have much larger accomodation. Outdoor ponds are ideal because indoor ponds are too much for many people. But otherwise massive tanks inside are fine for them.

its upset me mate,i have made a few comments that may not be welcomed.

[Graylord]

i don`t think organizing a witch hunt is the way to go eh?

mind you seems par for the course on here .

[mike515]

i think btt is the only one after the sellers head lol.


but dg you gotta admit that, that tank is way overstocked. no water change will fix that issue, it's just bad kishkeeping from what ever way you look at it

[Graylord]

And yes it does seem like an excessive amount of fish but shooting from the hip serves noone.

Look at Mike he keeps fish of gigantic sizes one could argue that their water to mass size isn`t correct either .

Though i can tell you know you wouldn`t get that opinion off me as i know he knows what he`s doing down to a fine art.

And for all we know the carp seller might be ( i am wearing my hat back to front on this one by the way)

[bullet tooth t0ny]

Originally Posted by darwengray

And yes it does seem like an excessive amount of fish but shooting from the hip serves noone.

Look at Mike he keeps fish of gigantic sizes one could argue that their water to mass size isn`t correct either .

Though i can tell you know you wouldn`t get that opinion off me as i know he knows what he`s doing down to a fine art.

And for all we know the carp seller might be ( i am wearing my hat back to front on this one by the way)

darwengray i am sorry for my comments and i didnt mean to aim them at you.wot gave me the right hump was the condition he was keeping them poor fish with a price tag of 70.i am a laid back person but it got under my skin.there was no care there wot so ever and its just about money.there are some good people on here that know their stuff.i know i was wrong what i said to you.maybe the forum thing is not for me as a dont like twats like that.i also dont like seeing people getting ripped off or a bad deal.

[Graylord]

Originally Posted by bullet tooth t0ny

darwengray i am sorry for my comments and i didnt mean to aim them at you.wot gave me the right hump was the condition he was keeping them poor fish with a price tag of 70.i am a laid back person but it got under my skin.there was no care there wot so ever and its just about money.there are some good people on here that know their stuff.i know i was wrong what i said to you.maybe the forum thing is not for me as a dont like twats like that.i also dont like seeing people getting ripped off or a bad deal.

no probs BTT we all have our opinions and i know you had the fishes welfare at heart