Quote:
Originally Posted by LadyP
Why do you think that gram negative bugs are not affected by soap but gram positives are?
|
There's a few recent studies that have shown that G- bacteria, with their protective outer membrane, are more resistant to many conventional anti-bacterial soaps.
G+ don't have the same level of protection from their outer membrane, and so are more susceptible to a wider variety of anti-bacterial substances, including some that are found in many soaps.
Stuff like this is pretty contentious, and there are some studies which "prove" things, at the same time as other studies "disproving" them...
Having had the opportunity to test several soaps, handwashes, mouthwashes and detergents in a lab setting, I am happy enough that a disc soaked in alcohol hand gel creates a larger "dead-zone" than one soaked in conventional soap; that makes me believe that it is more effective. When combined with studies that suggest that G- are resistant to many ingredients of soap, and having seen bacterial growth right up to the edge of the disc in some soaps, at lower concentrations (such as when mixed with water...), it would seem that they are far less effective at removing populations of G- bacteria than many of the handwash gels are.
I'd be interested in any evidence you have that suggests otherwise though - as I said, there are various studies that "prove" and "disprove" things about the antibacterial properties of soap, so anything that makes it clearer would be welcomed!!