P.O.T.M Discussions

[macro junkie]

Originally Posted by Katiexx

Well I typed Autumn barn into google images and this came up

so i'm guessing he just edited the cham in.

Well what do you think about that..do you think thats fair?

[spirit975]

Originally Posted by macro junkie

Well what do you think about that..do you think thats fair?

Not to sound too picky, but i don`t personally think its fair, and as per the rules:

One picture per user
No previous winning pictures (or extremely similar)
The picture has to be taken and owned by the person entering it
If photoshop or other editing programs used this must be stated
You must have been a member for 1 month & have 25+ posts
If you are a finalist and we see you creating new accounts for the purpose of voting, you will be disqualified (this includes friends and family accounts)

Sorry if its picky and its not just because i`ve entered this month. Anyone can choose a google pic and edit an animal into it. Its still a gorgeous photo, its just a shame the majority of it doesn`t belong to him....

[Esarosa]

Originally Posted by macro junkie

Well what do you think about that..do you think thats fair?

Nope I personally think it should be disqualified. Everyone could steal images off google and edit animals in, it's not in the spirit of competition, and it's not within the rules.

The picture should be taken by yourself, not a professional, not a husband, sister, uncle, giraffe etc..you get the point.

[macro junkie]

Originally Posted by Katiexx

Nope I personally think it should be disqualified. Everyone could steal images off google and edit animals in, it's not in the spirit of competition, and it's not within the rules.

The picture should be taken by yourself, not a professional, not a husband, sister, uncle, giraffe etc..you get the point.

i agree.

[Siman]

Not to sound rude but I personally think this is on a basis of the % of the picture that was googled and owned. For instance if a person took a photo and added a small amount of another image they hadn't taken but it was a ratio of say 90% theirs 10% not then I think personally that's fine. But in this case the chameleon is such a small part of the image and to be honest you have to sort of look out for it that I can't see why it would be allowed.

[Mark75]

Originally Posted by Siman

Not to sound rude but I personally think this is on a basis of the % of the picture that was googled and owned. For instance if a person took a photo and added a small amount of another image they hadn't taken but it was a ratio of say 90% theirs 10% not then I think personally that's fine. But in this case the chameleon is such a small part of the image and to be honest you have to sort of look out for it that I can't see why it would be allowed.

Tbh I think the % is irrelevant. The picture should be 100% your own content.

[Siman]

Originally Posted by Mark75

Tbh I think the % is irrelevant. The picture should be 100% your own content.

Which therefore would mean that a hell of a lot of lasts months finalists shouldn't have gotten through?

[Esarosa]

Originally Posted by Mark75

Tbh I think the % is irrelevant. The picture should be 100% your own content.

For things like the autumn theme I completely agree. The last months was a bit different what with the film/film poster theme though.

It's the fact he posted the picture and made out it was his own work that gets me though.

Originally Posted by Lizard-man

A Wee bit of editing of contrast and effect - Hope you like

[Siman]

Originally Posted by Katiexx

For things like the autumn theme I completely agree. The last months was a bit different what with the film/film poster theme though.

It's the fact he posted the picture and made out it was his own work that gets me though.

Agreed when I re-read what he put I did think it was a tad misleading....

[Papscrunt]

God i thought it was a class pic too but googling autumn barn its the 1st pic that comes up!!!
Well its supposed to be ur own work & i'm still green round here so i could have easily superimposed my cham onto something autumny for the comp but no instead i tried to make the leaves i had change in photoshop Not very good i know but it was the best i could think of at 2 in the morning