Well, that was...um... informative.
I have no problem with the first method, after hitting the wall the rat was very dead, very instantly! I could do that if I needed to, and next time the neighbour's cat leaves a mutilated mouse crawling around our deck I might try putting it out of its misery.
Sticking a live mouse in your freezer to die is the most horrendous thing I can think of. Slow and painful. Also, *tongue ever-so-slightly in cheek* not very environmentally friendly.... all that energy to freeze it only to have to waste more energy heating it back up again.
The thing he did with the pencil was not what I've read in books, where you hold the pencil to immobilize the skull, then pull sharply at the base of the tail to disconnect skull from spine and instantly sever the spinal cord. In theory should be a quicker death than his way, but I know there's no chance that I'd keep my nerve to do that.
The monitor did a pretty good job and the mouse died quickly, but the guy doesn't say that the speed of the mouse's death is not necessarily the main issue with live feeding. The problem is what can happen to your pet if he's not in the mood the eat his dinner straight away, or if his aim's a bit off and he leaves the bitey end of his dinner free to defend itself.
Ok... off to eat my breakfast now.... maybe
